Hello dear
Welcome To New York Pizza Plus Alachua
New York Pizza Plus Alachua is a delightful Italian eatery located at 15202 NW 147th Dr #100 in Alachua, Florida. Celebrated for its authentic dishes and inviting atmosphere, this restaurant boasts an impressive buffet featuring fresh and beautifully presented food. Customers rave about the outstanding flavors of the menu, including the savory Caprese pizza, succulent Veal Marsala, and perfectly executed Fried Calamari. The warm rolls served with olive oil and garlic are a must-try. With friendly service and generous portions, it's no wonder guests leave eager to return. This gem promises an exceptional dining experience for all Italian cuisine lovers.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Bruschetta
Kids Spaghetti and Meatballs
Original NY Stromboli
Steak and Cheese Stromboli
About
New York Pizza Plus Alachua
Welcome to New York Pizza Plus Alachua, a culinary gem located in the heart of Alachua, Florida. Nestled at 15202 NW 147th Dr #100, this restaurant boasts an eclectic menu that celebrates the rich and diverse flavors of Italian cuisine. With a strong commitment to quality and service, this establishment has quickly garnered rave reviews from satisfied customers.
Living up to its name, New York Pizza Plus Alachua is renowned for its authentic, hand-tossed pizzas. Each pie is crafted with fresh ingredients, ensuring that every bite is bursting with flavor. Diners like William Stein have praised the restaurant’s buffet, which features an impressive selection that consistently keeps the food fresh and enticing. Visitors can enjoy the bustling atmosphere, often a sign of quality and popularity among locals.
But the culinary journey doesn’t stop at pizza. Ashley Lynch and Matt B rave about the exceptional Italian dishes available here. From warm, buttery rolls drizzled with olive oil and garlic to the mouthwatering Caprese pizza, it’s clear that the kitchen is dedicated to delivering an authentic dining experience. The menu offers a plethora of Sicilian classics, like Clams appetizer, Veal Marsala, and Seafood Bisque, which have earned high marks from both new and returning patrons.
The service at New York Pizza Plus Alachua further enhances the dining experience. Friendly staff, including the welcoming owner who makes it a point to greet each table, ensure that you feel not just like a customer, but part of the family. Ray Miller highlighted the attentive staff and remarked on the delicious buffet selections, which range from tender chicken to perfectly seasoned tilapia, showcasing the culinary prowess of the chefs.
If you’re in search of a place that combines excellent food with a warm, inviting atmosphere, look no further than New York Pizza Plus Alachua. As Taylor Alford said, "this is the best pizza I've ever had." With fantastic prices and generous portions, this restaurant is a must-visit for both locals and travelers alike. Whether you are stopping by for a quick slice or indulging in a full course meal, prepare for a delightful experience that will leave you planning your next visit before you even leave the table!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Stopped by today for the buffet. Very impressive selection. Plus the restaurant was packed for lunch. That alone tells you something. Food was all fresh and well presented. Thanks for making ut a pleasant visit ”
“ This was an incredible restaurant! We were just passing through the city looking for a place to grab supper and happened to stumble upon this gem. Now, we’ll make it a point to stop here whenever we’re traveling through. The food was absolutely outstanding. Italian cuisine is my favorite, and this was hands down the best Italian food I’ve ever had. From the warm rolls served with olive oil and fresh garlic to the flavorful Caprese pizza, every dish we tried was delicious. The servers were all friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. Prices were very reasonable, especially given the generous portion sizes. The only thing I am disappointed about is that I don’t live closer. We will definitely be back! ”
“ Staff was friendly and helpful. Buffet (11am - 3pm) was delicious! Fish (tilapia?) was drenched in a delightful, light teriyaki sauce. Simple beef and mushrooms reminded me of an excellent bourguignon or cabernet sauvignon: tender, not overcooked and without all the extra vegetables. The chicken with sauteed rosemary potatoes practically fell off the bone and the potatoes were perfection, slight crust outside, tender on the inside. Pepperoni, ham and bacon had well balanced flavors. Made another trip to the buffet to try the stuffed zucchini (chicken, ham, minced onion, light bread, cheese? and white wine) well made, and the eggplant parmesan was also very good. Even the cucumber salad was just right - not too salty or sour. Kudos to the owner and his chefs - a delight to the pallette! Even the long-time patrons were quite congenial, giving high marks for the great quality freshness and variety of food. ”
“ Hands down the best and most authentic Italian food in North Florida. An absolute hidden gem. Great customer service from waitstaff and the owner that greets customers table side making you feel welcomed and relaxed. An authentic family style Italian restaurant serving up great Sicilian classics. We enjoyed the Clams appetizer, Veal Marsala, Chicken Gorgonzola, Fried Calamari, Seafood Bisque and the fresh baked hot rolls. We can’t wait to go back to try more of the authentic Italian dishes. ”
“ Genuinely this is the best pizza I've ever had. Staff is always so polite and friendly too! I'd give them more stars if I could! ”
“ First time ever coming to this place. Overall a scale to 1 to 10 on this restaurant. I give it a 9.5 . They let me take a look around for a good moment to see which side I would like either the buffet or dine in it did surprise me cuz it's the first time I ever seen a restaurant that did two-in-one The pizza (meat Lovers medium size) tasted really good And not too much toppings on it. Could have been cooked just a tad longer. The middle piece of the pizza was just a bit mushy but not too mushy for that pizza 1 out of 10 I give it a 8.5. The cannoli I got (chocolate) was really really good A good crunch to it not too much chocolate and the cream had a good flavor to it and it wasn't too sweet and a good size for a good price 1 out of 10 I give it a 9.5. The staff was very patient, very polite and very professional. Overall I'll give everything a five star cuz it was good than most pizza places here ”
“ This was a great choice for lunch today. We had no idea where we wanted to eat and decided to see what was in Alachua. Rose down to the end of the street and decided to stop here. What a great sour of the moment idea! Food was great, very fresh and tasty. Our order was delivered very quickly and the staff was friendly and very helpful. We could only eat half of the generous portions! It was all so delicious and we enjoyed our meal very much! ”
“ Today I ordered a Build your own Stromboli. It was super yummy and I would definitely order it again. I have also ordered lasagna and salad from the Catering menu. It comes with the garlic rolls, which are amazing. It is a crowd favorite. ”